Pilot purgatory is what happens when a construction technology pilot works on one job and then never goes anywhere. BiltOn is designed for enterprise GCs that want a safety pilot to end in a decision, so this guide covers how to set one up to scale. For innovation and IT leaders, the real test is data integrity, security, and integrations that hold up at scale.
If you run innovation or construction technology at a large GC, you have probably lived this. The project team liked the tool, the vendor sent a nice recap, and a year later the company is still running four platforms that do the same thing. Our post on building the standard for Safety Intelligence explains why we care about getting this right.
Pilot purgatory: A state where a technology pilot keeps running, or keeps getting repeated, without a clear decision to scale it or stop it.
Enterprise rollout: Standardizing one platform across every project and business unit under a single agreement and configuration.
Safety Intelligence: Verified field data turned into signals leaders can act on before a problem becomes a loss.
Predictive Safety Management: The operating model that uses verified leading indicators to act early instead of counting failures later.
Why do so many construction tech pilots stall?
Pilots stall because they are set up to prove a tool works, not to prove the business should change how it operates. Without a baseline, an owner, and a scaling decision date, a good pilot turns into an anecdote.
McKinsey's research on digital transformation in construction opens with a large contractor that spent five years on pilots without seeing improvements. McKinsey also notes that only 16% of organizations across industries said their transformations had both improved performance and sustained the gains.
The construction-specific barriers are well documented. In a 2018 study reported by Construction Dive, 61% of contractors named worker acceptance as one of their top barriers to new technology.
Scale itself is hard in this industry. McKinsey's Imagining construction's digital future points out that rolling out solutions across dispersed sites is difficult, and that subcontractors vary widely in digital sophistication. It also found construction spends less than 1% of revenue on IT.
Field reality is the other half. The Autodesk and FMI Construction Disconnected report found that 75% of contractors give superintendents mobile devices, but only 18% of them consistently use mobile apps to pull data or collaborate. Tool sprawl makes it worse. Each new point tool adds another login, another data silo, and another security review.
Here are the patterns we see most often when a pilot stalls:
No baseline: Nobody measured the old process, so there is nothing to compare against.
Wrong problem: The pilot solves an IT wish list instead of a field pain point.
One champion: Everything depends on one person, and that person changes jobs.
No integration plan: The tool sits beside Procore or Autodesk instead of connecting to them.
No decision date: The pilot has a start date but no date when leadership decides.
What does pilot purgatory cost a large GC?
It costs money twice. You pay for overlapping tools and duplicate data entry, and you lose the value the better tool would have delivered across the portfolio.
Duplicate entry is the hidden bill. The JBKnowledge ConTech Report found 51.3% of respondents still manually transfer data between apps that do not integrate, and 23.6% said none of their apps integrate.
Bad data adds up fast. Autodesk and FMI's Harnessing the Data Advantage in Construction estimated bad data cost the global industry $1.848 trillion in 2020, and found that one-third of poor decisions were caused by bad data.
Construction Disconnected put a time number on it. Construction professionals spent 35% of their time, more than 14 hours a week, on non-productive activities like looking for project data and fixing mistakes.
Pilot purgatory | Enterprise rollout |
|---|---|
Several tools doing the same job | One configured platform |
Data entered twice, by hand | Two-way sync with Procore or Autodesk |
Results reported as stories | Results measured against a baseline |
Training restarts on every new job | Workers and staff carry the same setup job to job |
Renewal decided by habit | Renewal decided by measurables |
How do you design a pilot that is meant to scale?
Design the pilot like a business case from day one. Pick a real field problem, record the baseline, agree on the metrics, and set the date when leadership will decide.
Skanska USA offers a useful model. Danielle O'Connell, senior director of emerging technology, told Construction Dive that Skanska's Eight-Step Plan starts with identifying the problem. She said pilots typically run at least a year or the duration of a project.
She also described vetting technology the way you vet a risky subcontractor. That framing helps safety and risk leaders see why the process takes time.
A simple pilot charter covers five things:
The problem: One field pain point, stated in the field's words.
The baseline: How the work runs today, measured on comparable projects.
The metrics: Three to five measurables leadership already cares about.
The owners: A field champion, an executive sponsor, and an IT partner.
The decision: A date and the threshold that triggers an enterprise agreement.
Lemartec, a MasTec building group GC, made the comparison the center of its pilot. "Safety is a priority, but you just can't have a magical wish list," said Dwayne Jenkins, now Senior Director of Environmental, Health and Safety for MasTec's building group. Leadership wanted measurables, so the pilot was benchmarked against the projects still running the old way. Scope the security review and the integrations up front. A bi-directional Procore API integration keeps data flowing both ways, and structured field data capture keeps the records clean.

Which metrics convince leadership to scale?
Leadership scales a tool when the numbers tie to time, risk, and cost they already track. Adoption metrics matter, but only when they connect to an outcome.
For a safety platform, a strong scorecard usually includes:
Routine completion: Pre-task plan and JHA completion rates by trade, compared with the baseline.
Close-out speed: Days to close observations and corrective actions.
Admin time: Hours safety staff spend scanning, filing, and chasing paperwork.
Trade partner adoption: How fast subs use the tool, including features nobody told them to use.
Record quality: How quickly a complete record can be pulled for an inspector, carrier, or claim.
Our post on why consistent safety platform adoption decides your insurance premiums explains why the adoption numbers matter to carriers too. For the difference between activity counts and real signals, see leading vs lagging safety indicators. Add data integrity to the scorecard. When every record lands in one place, you get a single source of truth that leadership can trust.
Customer proof point: Hunter Roberts. Within six months, pre-shift plan completion rose from 67% to 98% across the portfolio, and observation close-out time dropped from 9 days to 4.2 days (client-reported). Those are the kinds of before-and-after numbers that move a pilot to a decision. Hunter Roberts case study
How do you win the field during the pilot?
You win the field by making the tool easier than the old way on day one. If crews have to download an app, create a login, or change their routine, adoption stalls before the data shows up.
That is why BiltOn lets workers sign PTPs by SMS or browser with no app download, and ties every signature to a verified worker profile. The BiltOn v53 release explains how that works.
Involving the crew is also good safety practice. OSHA's guidance on worker participation calls for workers to be involved in all aspects of a safety program, including contractor and temporary workers. Our guide to the pre-task plan template every crew will actually use covers the crew side, and why pre-task plans fail covers the sub side.
Dwayne Jenkins is candid about the early resistance at Lemartec. "Humans do not like change," he says. Lemartec shared what was working as the pilot ran, so project directors and PMs on the next jobs inherited a case that was made in front of them.
Recognition helps as well. When BiltOn released digital permits, three Lemartec subcontractors filled out a hot work permit the same day without being asked, and Dwayne made sure they were called out for it.

When should a pilot become an enterprise agreement?
A pilot should become an enterprise agreement when the benchmark is clear and the next projects are already asking for it. At that point, buying one job at a time costs more in admin and inconsistency than it saves.
Lemartec reached that point fast. "The biggest thing is just consistency," Dwayne says. Because BiltOn syncs with Procore, nobody builds folders by hand, and people who move between projects keep the same setup. Once one project worked and four more were lined up, he said, "it already makes sense to go enterprise."
Integration is usually what decides it. BiltOn provides two-way sync with Procore and Autodesk, so safety records live where the project team already works. See how Procore and Autodesk customers use BiltOn for the details.
McKinsey's advice lines up with this. Its five practices include solving business pain points rather than IT problems, reskilling people, adjusting baselines, and connecting projects across the enterprise. At this point, ask for enterprise deployment on a centralized tenant. One master agreement and one standard beat a patchwork of site-by-site setups.

How does consolidating tools fit into scaling a pilot?
Scaling a pilot is often the best chance you will get to retire overlapping tools. A platform that covers more of the safety workflow lets you cut subscriptions, training, and data entry at the same time.
BiltOn covers orientations, PTPs, JHAs captured from trade partners at the source, permits, observations, inspections, incident reports, and COI and certification tracking. Our construction safety inspection software buyer's guide offers a checklist for comparing platforms.
AI interest makes this more urgent. The 2026 AGC and Sage Outlook found 61% of firms use AI or plan to increase AI investment, up from 44%. Those tools are only as good as the field data underneath them.
The 2026 Dodge and CPWR safety management study found that predictive analytics are used frequently by fewer than 10% of contractors. Clean, consistent data across every project is the step before that. Fewer tools means less tool sprawl, fewer integrations to maintain, and a smaller security surface to review.
What should each leader own?
Each leader owns a part of the scaling decision. Clear ownership is what keeps a strong pilot from drifting.
For Innovation and IT leaders: Write the pilot charter, set the integration plan, and own the decision date. Run security and data reviews early. Own security, integrations, and data integrity from day one.
For VPs of Safety and Safety Directors: Own the baseline and the field scorecard. Read how safety directors use intelligent workflows.
For COOs and VPs of Operations: Sponsor the pilot and decide on scale when the threshold is met.
For CFOs and heads of Risk: Count retired tools and admin hours, and bring the adoption data to your carrier. See how Safety Intelligence turns jobsite data into lower insurance costs.
Ready to scope a pilot that is designed to scale? Book a walkthrough at BiltOn demo.
Executive takeaway
Most pilots stall because they lack a baseline, an owner, and a decision date.
Pilot purgatory costs twice, through overlapping tools and through value that never reaches the portfolio.
A good pilot charter names one field problem, the baseline, the metrics, the owners, and the decision.
Field adoption depends on making the tool easier than the old way, with no app download for crews.
Integration with Procore or Autodesk and clear benchmarks are what turn a pilot into an enterprise agreement.
Judge a pilot on security, integrations, and data integrity, not only on logins.
Frequently asked questions
1. What is pilot purgatory in construction?
Pilot purgatory is when a technology pilot keeps running, or keeps getting repeated, without a decision to scale or stop it. McKinsey describes a large contractor that ran pilots for five years without seeing improvements.
2. How long should a construction technology pilot last?
Long enough to see the tool across real project conditions. Skanska USA's pilots typically run at least a year or the duration of a project, according to Construction Dive.
3. What metrics should a safety software pilot track?
Track routine completion, close-out speed, admin hours, trade partner adoption, and how fast you can pull a complete record. Compare each against projects still on the old process.
4. Why do field teams resist new construction technology?
Worker acceptance is one of the most cited barriers, named by 61% of contractors in a Dodge study reported by Construction Dive. Tools that add steps or logins tend to lose the field.
5. How does BiltOn support an enterprise rollout?
BiltOn offers SMS and browser signing with no app download, verified worker profiles, and two-way sync with Procore and Autodesk. Learn more in what is Predictive Safety Management.
Works Cited
Associated General Contractors of America and Sage. (2026). Dampened expectations: The 2026 construction hiring and business outlook
Autodesk and FMI. (2021). Harnessing the data advantage in construction
Autodesk and FMI. (2018). Construction disconnected
Construction Dive. (2018). Dodge: Worker acceptance, IT integration top challenges to construction tech adoption
Construction Dive. (2025). Adopting technology is a team effort: Skanska exec
Dodge Construction Network and CPWR. (2026). Safety management in the construction industry SmartMarket report
JBKnowledge. (2021). The ConTech report
McKinsey and Company. (2016). Imagining construction's digital future
McKinsey and Company. (2019). Decoding digital transformation in construction
Occupational Safety and Health Administration. (n.d.). Recommended practices for safety and health programs: Worker participation
Stay Informed
Get the latest safety intelligence insights.
Join safety leaders and risk professionals who rely on BiltOn's newsletter for industry insights, research, and best practices.
